Former WWE star Indi Hartwell has expressed interest in reuniting with her former on-screen husband, Dexter Lumis, now that both wrestlers are part of Total Nonstop Action Wrestling (TNA). Hartwell has indicated that she would welcome another chapter for their popular on-screen pairing, known to fans as “InDex.”
The possibility of their reunion has generated interest among wrestling fans who remember the duo’s unusual but entertaining relationship storyline during their time in WWE’s developmental brand, NXT.
Indi Hartwell Says She Is Open to Reuniting With Dexter Lumis
Hartwell recently discussed the prospect of working with Lumis again during an interview about her wrestling career and future opportunities. She explained that fans continue to bring up their partnership at autograph signings, conventions and wrestling events, even years after the original storyline.
The wrestler described the InDex storyline as one of the most enjoyable experiences of her career. She also expressed pride in the work they did together and suggested that the story still has room for further development.
Hartwell indicated that both performers are interested in exploring the partnership again. In her view, their WWE storyline never received a definitive conclusion, leaving the possibility of a continuation open.
Her comments suggest that a reunion would not simply be a nostalgic appearance. Instead, it could provide an opportunity to revisit a relationship that remains memorable to a section of the wrestling audience.
Why the InDex Storyline Became Popular
Hartwell and Lumis developed their on-screen relationship during their time in NXT. Their contrasting personalities helped make the pairing distinctive, with Hartwell's expressive character complementing Lumis' quiet and mysterious presentation.
The storyline eventually culminated in an on-screen wedding, making the duo one of the more recognisable couples from that period of NXT programming.
Their partnership became known as InDex, a combination of their ring names. The storyline attracted a dedicated following, and its popularity has endured beyond their original run together.
Hartwell's recent remarks underline that the audience's interest has not disappeared. She said the pairing continues to come up in conversations with fans, demonstrating how certain character-driven stories can maintain their appeal long after their initial television run.
Both Wrestlers Are Now in TNA
The prospect of a reunion has become more realistic because Hartwell and Lumis are now associated with the same wrestling promotion.
Hartwell joined TNA after leaving WWE in 2024, continuing her career outside the company where she first gained wider recognition. Lumis, meanwhile, has also moved to TNA, where he is working under the ring name Samuel Shaw.
Their presence in the same promotion creates an opportunity for the two wrestlers to collaborate again if creative plans and scheduling allow.
However, their shared roster status does not automatically mean a reunion has been officially confirmed. No specific date, match or storyline has been announced as part of Hartwell's comments.
What Could a Reunion Mean for TNA?
Bringing InDex back together could allow TNA to draw on an established wrestling storyline with an existing fan following. Their history provides a foundation for new character developments, whether through a continuing relationship angle, a backstage segment or a more substantial role in the promotion's programming.
Hartwell's comments make clear that she is enthusiastic about the idea, particularly because she believes the original story still lacks closure. Whether TNA chooses to pursue it remains to be seen.
For now, fans have a clear indication that Hartwell is willing to revisit one of the most memorable partnerships of her WWE career. With both performers now in TNA, the possibility of seeing InDex together again is open, even though no official reunion has been confirmed.
